Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
CarmelResident.org
 

 
Welcome to CarmelResident.org Message Board. This message board provides an opportunity for residents, public officials and community organizations to convey ideas, community announcements and viewpoints concerning issues affecting individuals and the community as a whole. The Message Board is an open forum inviting responsible comments and dialogues on any topic of interest to participants. Messages considered to be profane or abusive to individuals or groups will be removed. This is a free message board and is provided as a community service. We cannot be responsible for the content on this site. Please do not accept the validity of any information on the message board without first verifying it independently. IN ORDER TO POST ON THIS BOARD, YOU MUST BE A REGISTERED MEMBER AND YOU MUST ABIDE BY THE REGISTRATION AGREEMENT. Thank you and enjoy the message board.

If you have any questions, send an e-mail to an Administrator.
  HomeHelpSearchLoginRegister  
 
Pages: 1
Send Topic Print
Just when you thought it was safe... (Read 74 times)
jeffgreen
CRMB Full Member
***
Offline



Posts: 132

Just when you thought it was safe...
06/21/10 at 18:16:16
 
Ed note: PlanPutnam and News That Matters is proud to be in the lead on this issue as we were exposing the "contract" at Tilly Foster, defeating the forestry project atop Mount Nimham and saving the Croton Waterhsed by defeating the sewage diversion program. But we cannot do it without your help and assistance. Stop in over at News That Matters and sign up to get the newsletter delivered to your email box or RSS feed.

Following on the past two stories about this, News That Matters published the following this morning.

The original story, Corporate Welfare, Putnam Style is here:

Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!!  You need to Login or Register!!


For the links below to work, and for the full article, please visit News That Matters here:

Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!!  You need to Login or Register!!



Just When You Thought…. Redux

Sometimes it seems we’re living in a world that even Franz Kafka could not have envisioned and that Philip K. thingy  has never had even in wildest nightmares. The Russian bureaucracy of Kafka’s day has nothing on Putnam County today. For just when you think it’s safe to go on about your lives our elected officials do something so outrageous that you want to take the entire lot and have them locked in stocks along Lake Gleneida. Just such an event took place last week when a letter from Vincent Tamagna, written on official Legislative stationary, ended up as an insert in the Putnam County News and Reporter. (Tamagna Letter)

I don’t know about the legality of such and as far as I can tell his use of the Legislature’s letterhead is, at the very least, unethical, as it gives the impression that body supports and endorses the position outlined inside. And what position is that? Yeah, you guessed it: it’s a ham-fisted, illogical treatise on how giving Paul Camarda $3.7 million taxpayers dollars to upgrade highway infrastructure near his proposed Patterson Crossing project isn’t giving Paul Camarda $3.7 million taxpayer dollars, that somehow it’s different.

Yeah, as different as apples and apples.

In the letter, Vinnie T says there’s a safety issue so important that we cannot wait another day else a school bus filled with high school cheerleaders is rear-ended by a prison van filled with level 3, syphilitic sex offenders bent on mayhem. And the environmental concerns are do dire that if we don’t fix them at this very moment, Lake Carmel will shrivel and dry up leading to the discovery of an old bicycle or two – and Jimmy Hoffa’s body.

And while I could go after his letter line by line and word by word exposing every twist and turn and paranoid fantasy, I’d rather have my eyes gored out by a rusty nail – yeah, it’s the most inane piece of crap I’ve almost ever seen coming from an elected person. (Though the County Executive on his best days can do better.) And though he claims there has been “misinformation” concerning the issue (which he never explores) I have just one question to ask Mr. Tamagna: Which part of the following don’t you understand?

   From Camarda Development’s website about the project they have this:

           Center will pay for the vast majority of high-cost road and stormwater improvements needed to address existing problems

   I’ll grant that it’s in the small print and is the very last line on the page, but as of 8:44AM on May 25th, 2010, it’s there and the language is clear. “Center will pay….”

   In the Final Environmental Impact Statement for the project dated July 17, 2008 and available here (PDF), we read the following:

           The FEIS has identified several improvements that will be completed by the Project Sponsor [emphasis, mine] to mitigate the increase in traffic resulting from the retail center including:

           • NYS Route 311 at the Project entrance would be improved with right and left turn lanes and a new traffic signal;
           • At the Fair Street/NYS Route 311 intersection the curb radii will be widened;
           • At the NYS Route 311/Interstate 84 Westbound ramp a left turn lane, off-ramp turn lane, signalization and queue detection will be added; and
           • At the NYS Route 311/Interstate 84 Eastbound ramp a left turn lane, off-ramp turn lane, signalization and queue detection will be added.

The rest can be read in an article called, “Corporate Welfare, Putnam Style” posted on May 25th to the News That Matters website.

Read More here:

Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!!  You need to Login or Register!!
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Ann_Fanizzi
CRMB Almighty Contributor
*****
Offline

 

Posts: 595

Re: Just when you thought it was safe...
Reply #1 - 06/22/10 at 07:06:00
 
Jeff - we are all aware of the insert letter by Tamagna and it is a shame that you cannot forego the temptation for self-promotion and exaggeration - "saving the Croton Watershed".  Many participated in the diversion battle foremost of whom was George Baum who lost his position as CAC Chairman and the county CAC was unceremoniously disbanded.  

As for Nimham, I take my hat off to you but again many participated in the DEC finally surrendering its misguided plan.  

As for Tilly Foster, from the beginning you were opposed to its preservation, derided efforts to do so and for a decade have carried on an unrelenting battle against it.

Tamagna's actions are reprehensible and should be vigorously opposed.  Whether there will be a resolution of reprimand or outright censure, I do not know as of this hour, what steps the Legislature will take.  But certainly Jeff we should unite in this effort and forego the chest thumping.

 

Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
jeffgreen
CRMB Full Member
***
Offline



Posts: 132

Re: Just when you thought it was safe...
Reply #2 - 06/22/10 at 07:45:11
 
Jeez, Ann. Let your ego go for a just a moment and allow some space for the rest of us. I don't know why, even after all these years, you can't simply allow others to exist. You really do get me down and bring down good deeds with you.
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Twist
CRMB Senior Member
****
Offline



Posts: 471

Re: Just when you thought it was safe...
Reply #3 - 06/23/10 at 14:47:42
 
From Mike Santos:

[Brewster10509] Re: County Legislature responds to public‏
From:  brewster10509@yahoogroups.com on behalf of Mike Santos (villagetrustee2003@yahoo.com)  
Sent: Wed 6/23/10 3:35 PM
To:  Brewster10509@yahoogroups.com
Cc:  Patterson12563 (patterson12563@yahoogroups.com)

First, I want to thank Legislator Tony Hay [R-Southeast] for drafting this resolution.  I had been hard on Tony when we disagreed on his vote in favor of the proposed landfill consolidation, and I want to be equally explicit in my praise for his sensitivity to public opinion on the proposed corporate welfare for Patterson Crossing.

Second, I want to thank Legislator Dan Birmingham [R-Brewster] for publicly supporting this draft resolution, and for his previous and persistent opposition to the Road Improvement District scheme.

Last, and certainly most important, I want to thank everyone who sent an e-mail, signed a petition, made a phone call, or otherwise made their voice heard in this matter.

The draft resolution clearly states: "...the Road Improvement District had generated a tremendous volume of comments from the public...."  

Your voice was heard loud and clear.

The moral of the story is that our relationship with our governments is much like any other relationship we have in life.  If we invest some time, attention and effort into the relationship, it is likely to be successful.  If we don't, the relationship is likely to sour.

Government works, but only as well as we work to make it work.
Members of the County Legislature last night drafted a resolution, which will be debated and voted upon next week, to restrict the efforts of County Legislature Chairman Vincent Tamagna [R-Philipstown] to involve the county government in funding, in whole or in part, the proposed Road Improvement District for the intersection of I-84 and Route 311.

The controversial proposal would have used county sales tax revenues, up to $3.7 million, to pay for road improvements at or near the site of the planned Patterson Crossing shopping center.

I am informed that the resolution was drafted by Legislator Tony Hay [R-Southeast] , and has the strong support of Legislator Dan Birmingham [R-Brewster] .

The key language in the Draft Resolution is "...that the Chairman of the Putnam County Legislature is prohibited on behalf of the Legislature from writing letters or lobbying New York State or Federal officials to partner with the County for any road improvement district whereby the County is to share in the cost of a road improvement district that will benefit a private developer without a corresponding resolution of approval of the Putnam County Legislature. ..."

The full text of the draft resolution is posted below my signature line.  

MIKE SANTOS

"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Ben Franklin

The Full Text of the Draft Resolution:

           WHEREAS, at a Special Meeting of the Putnam County Legislature on May 26, 2010, Item #4 on the agenda( Approval/Road Improvement District/Route 311 & I-84) was withdrawn from the agenda; and

           WHEREAS, prior to that scheduled Special Meeting, the Road Improvement District had generated a tremendous volume of comments from the public; and

WHEREAS, since the withdrawal of this agenda item, there has been what appears to be a single sided dialogue on the matter with a newspaper article which stated that a request may be made to the State to share half the cost with the County for a Road Improvement District and recently a position letter was inserted into a local newspaper with the Legislative Chairman’s opinion on this matter, now therefore be it

RESOLVED, that the Putnam County Legislature will not share any current or proposed County sales tax revenues nor will it expend any taxpayer dollars to offset the cost of any road improvement district required of a developer to complete a project; and be it further

RESOLVED, that the Chairman of the Putnam County Legislature is prohibited on behalf of the Legislature from writing letters or lobbying New York State or Federal officials to partner with the County for any road improvement district whereby the County is to share in the cost of a road improvement district that will benefit a private developer without a corresponding resolution of approval of the Putnam County Legislature; and be it further

RESOLVED, that this resolution shall not prohibit any Legislator from writing letters, lobbying or acting in his/her sole capacity as a Putnam County Legislator.
Back to top
 
« Last Edit: 06/23/10 at 19:49:58 by Twist »  
View Profile   IP Logged
jeffgreen
CRMB Full Member
***
Offline



Posts: 132

Re: Just when you thought it was safe...
Reply #4 - 06/23/10 at 18:30:44
 
Twist,

You beat me to that post by only a few minutes. It's good news but not what the Legislature needed to do and that's to ask Mr. Tamagna to step down from the chair. They won't because that would do two things: admit they're messed up and second, allow Maryellen O'Dell to take the Chairmanship and they don't want to do that when Uncle Vinnie is destined to be County Executive and he doesn't need the competition. It's one nifty little county we live in.

The good news, all on its own, is that the County Legislature has heard our voices and has killed the corporate welfare proposal. However, this won't stop Paul Camarda who will head on up a level and see what he can get from the state and that's where we need to concentrate next.

   Call:

       * Acting Regional Director for NYSDOT Region 8, William Gorton at (845) 431-5750
       * Sandy Galef (914) 941-1111 (GalefS@assembly.state.ny.us)
       * Greg Ball, (845) 279-5301 (or contact here) and,
       * State Senator Vinnie Leibell (845) 279-3773 (or contact here)


Jeff
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Ann_Fanizzi
CRMB Almighty Contributor
*****
Offline

 

Posts: 595

Re: Just when you thought it was safe...
Reply #5 - 06/24/10 at 06:27:27
 
Although we are facing this most immediate threat, there are other instances of corporate welfare winding their way through the Town of Southeast Board.  Two of these are Brewster Honda and DeCiccio.  

Tonight both of these corporate entities: Brewster Honda who through their attorney and coopted Town Planner is attempting to re-write the Comprehensive Plan and Zoning Code so as to fufill Honda's corporate expansion plan.  No effort or expense has been spared in their drive to warp the very nature of comprehension plan revision which rests on community initiation, consensus and approval.

The second is DeCiccio. Talk about corporate welfare. I have written about this particular grocery store chain presently located in the former D'Agostino site in Yorktown, in another post entitled "Shop Putnam is a Dud."  Tonight in one felt swoop, the Town will hold a public hearing on their effort to obtain a Federal block grant; will review the Environmental Assessment Form; will determine significance and then approve.  

According to the application, the amount of assistance funds to shoehorn this business next to Kohl's on Brewster Highlands is as follows:

$635,000 from the block grant
$400,000 owner equity
$2,450,000 private financing???
$165,000 Empire State Development Corporation
$500,000 - landlord Renovation Incentive Rebate.  The landlord is Harold Leplar.  

Within the context of "Shop Putnam" do we need another grocery store chain who will employ 73 workers, one-half of whom according to the application will earn less than $40,000? Clerks, mozzarella makers and wrappers and a pastry chef.   Richard Ruchela who as chair of the County Empire State Committee thinks so.  It will be a terrific addition to sales tax revenue.  So what if there are other stores (Hannaford, ShopRite, A&P, Key Food) plus Ace Endico across the way that I could go.  And guess what it meets Empire State requirement that manufacturing jobs be created.  Manufacturing mozzarella??? Take-out dinners?

By the way, there has been silence from those who should be opposing this grab and this charade tonight.  How about it Mike Santos?? Angry



Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Ann_Fanizzi
CRMB Almighty Contributor
*****
Offline

 

Posts: 595

Re: Just when you thought it was safe...
Reply #6 - 06/25/10 at 07:06:06
 
What a sad night in Southeast:  a town board ceding control of the town's economic destiny to corporations, being accountable to them instead of residents.  And the admission by the chair of the ZBA that we can't attract a fly and have to accept whatever comes along, was stunning.   I'm going to get his exact words and let them speak for themselves.  Cry
Back to top
 
 
View Profile   IP Logged
Pages: 1
Send Topic Print